The Art of Authenticating Large Hat Pins

In the world of vintage fashion accessories, large hat pins are a fascinating area of collecting. With their rich history and ornate designs, it's no wonder why enthusiasts are eager to add these exquisite pieces to their collections. But how do you know if your large hat pin is authentic? In this article, we'll explore the key indicators that separate true antiques from reproductions.

Branded Pieces

Take, for instance, brands like Charles Horner and Pearce & Thompson. While many branded pieces were marked in European manufacturing based on their country's requirements for marking precious metals, it's essential to note that fine examples rarely exceed prices above $100 unless they feature expensive materials such as precious gemstones and metals or belong to a historically significant figure.

Additional Value

Hatpins with actual branding information on them add some value to their final prices. This is because the brand name and marking serve as proof of authenticity, making it easier for collectors to verify its history and worth.

Condition Matters

Antique hatpins were pushed and used, so it wouldn't be uncommon to find them bent or misshapen. However, if a piece of antique jewelry or hatpin has an unusual shape or is heavily damaged, it may not be as valuable.

Materials Matter

There was no stainless steel being used during the height of hatpin production, so you shouldn't be buying hatpins with stainless steel stems. Instead, look for pieces featuring natural materials like wood, metal, and precious stones.

Balance is Key

Consider how the hatpin would look when put through a hat. If it's too heavy or doesn't display well, it may not be an authentic piece. Authentic hatpins are designed to complement hats, not overwhelm them.

Period-Accurate Colors and Stones

Being aware of colors and materials that were typical of that era is helpful. Look for pieces featuring amethyst, amber, and other stones that were popular during the height of hatpin production.

No Soldering

Authentic hatpins do not show solder, except for the military buttons made into hatpins during World War I. If you notice any signs of soldering or artificial joining, it may be a reproduction.

Centered Findings

Look for the finding to be centered properly in the middle of the back of the hatpin. Check to see that it hasn't been artificially joined or soldered together. A well-centered finding is a hallmark of an authentic piece.

Head and Stem Joints

Examine the 'finding,' or the piece that joins the hatpin head to the stem. If it's securely attached and shows no signs of artificial joining, it may be an antique.

Rhinestones

Contemporary rhinestones have low tables (cut down lower on the stone), while vintage rhinestones tended to have high tables (where the top is cut off the stone). Additionally, vintage rhinestones were often prong set or bezel set, rather than glued in.

By examining these key indicators, you can increase your chances of owning an authentic antique hat pin. Remember that while there are no hard-and-fast ways to tell if a hatpin is true, these subtle clues can help you separate the genuine pieces from reproductions. Happy collecting!

Large hat pins